katallison: (giles fresh hell)
katallison ([personal profile] katallison) wrote2003-09-21 07:30 pm

In Which Kat Suffers for her Art

So, I had an entry half-written about my annoying week, and then I deleted it, thinking, "Dear god, bad enough I should have to live through my annoying week, why inflict it on my friends?" And instead I shall burble at length about my adventures as an utter newbie in vidding, which are probably even more tedious than the-week-in-retrospect, but may give the more expert vidders in the reading audience a nostalgic glow for their own early days, and convince the non-vidders that they are truly much better off sticking to writing.

So--since my own writing is still in the not-happening place, I decided to spend the weekend messing around with Premiere, which, let me just say at the outset, is the Thrice-Accursed Hose-Beast. I thought I'd start with a fairly simple idea to which I'm not deeply attached, namely a Victoria (of dS) vid to June Tabor's "Pavanne," which is a lovely sad song about a bad, bad woman. The plusses here are that this would allow me to use source from only two episodes, which makes finding clips easier; and the aforementioned lack of emotional attachment, which means if I totally flub, no biggie.

First step: import the audio into Premiere. I had the song downloaded from eMusic, and all I needed to do was convert it from MP3 to WAV, which is at least something I already knew how to do (the only step in this entire adventure of which I have mastery, I might say). So I converted, saved, opened Premiere, imported, hit Play, and -- nothing. I could see the little squiggly waveforms on the timeline indicating that there was indeed audio there, but no sound. I fiddled, I dithered, I clicked many buttons and studied many menus, I read through the Premiere manual, all to no avail.

(And may I just say that the Premiere manual is perhaps the worst freakin' piece of technical documentation I've ever encountered, at least when it comes to helping people whose way of learning new software is to jump right in and start dinking around. I don't really know who it is designed for, except maybe people who already know how to use Premiere. Grrrrr.)

I rendered. I changed settings. I trashed the entire thing and started over. Nothing, nada, rien. Finally I closed it and went to bed (this was yesterday), thinking (with the wan hope I often bring to computer fuck-ups) that if I just let it sit for a while and reflect on its sins, it'd come around and snap into shape.

Opened it again today, and again, no sound. Also, I discovered, no capturing of video from the DVD player, once I'd done all the plugging-in of cords. I started wondering about capturing directly from the computer's DVD player, recollecting that I'd seen a thread about this on the Vidder list not long ago, and went digging through the list archives, wherein I found a bunch of fearsomely intimidating technical posts about codecs and what-not, but also stumbled across a post by the lovely [livejournal.com profile] jackiekjono answering someone's query about why she couldn't get audio to play in Premiere. Go to Project Settings, quoth Jackie, and change the settings in this particular way, and you shall have audio. And I went and changed settings thusly, and lo! The audio played! And there was much rejoicing.

I phoned over to the House of Jackie and Carol, and got the lovely Carol (aka [livejournal.com profile] lapillus) on the phone, and burbled happily, and then, lofted on the updraft of mad optimism, said, "OK, so -- the next thing is, I need to cut a verse out of the middle of the song. Hah hah! That must be easy, right?" Carol assured me that this quite easy, all I needed to do was use the Razor tool. I said, "Razor tool! Right! I know where that is!" And I hung up and returned to Premiere.

And yes, I did know where the Razor tool was, and I clicked at the point where I wanted to start cutting, and I clicked at the point where I wanted to stop cutting, and then I sat and stared at the screen for a while. So -- uh, how do you get the stuff you want to excise out of the middle of the track? Back to the Premiere manual, whose brief section on the Razor tool is a masterpiece of unhelpful obfuscation. Back to the clicking around, and the studying of menus. And eventually, back to the phone, redial the House of Carol and Jackie, and this time I got Jackie on the phone, who said, "Oh, sure, all you need to do is select the part you want to delete, and then delete it!" And I went and did that, and lo, it worked! I felt a bit like Gandalf standing in front of the gates of Moria, having just realized Duh, dumbfuck, all you hadda do was say "Friend"!

Carol and Jackie had both warned me that getting the two remaining chunks of audio smoothly meshed at their join might require some tweaking and fiddling, BUT -- when I dragged the two together, and plunked them down, and hit "Play" -- by god, they flowed smooth as you please. I mean, it might not pass muster with an audio engineer, or with anyone listening for a join, but, y'know, good enough for government work.

That accomplished, I went back to the issue of capturing, and after much futzing, established that:

--if I keep the settings in "Project Settings-->General" where they need to be to hear audio, I can't capture;
--if I change them so that I can capture, I can't hear audio;
--in any event, I can only capture from the VCR and not from the DVD player, though in each case I have the same set of cords plugged into what looks like similar "Line Out" jacks.

These arcane mysteries remain to be plumbed. For now, I have shut down Premiere (Evil! Hose Beast!) and am refreshing myself with a fine malted beverage. I have not done the two things I really should have done this evening, namely a) visit my dad in the hospital, and b) go to the gym. But my dad seemed to be perfectly fine when I was there this morning (as distinct from last night, when we had a trip to the ER and a reprise of "I think he may be dying this time -- um, oops, guess not, he's going to be fine"). And the gym will always be there tomorrow.

Oh, and also? Carol and Jackie will, as my mother used to say, be wearing stars in their crowns in the Great Hereafter. I'm just saying.

[identity profile] destina.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 05:59 pm (UTC)(link)
This amuses me greatly, for lo, I was as you are, not so very long ago, when I was learning how to use Studio 8. In my case, it took me weeks to figure out how to overcome a technical glitch and make the program capture. Fortunately or unfortunately, depending on your POV, my CD drive broke before I could install Premiere and begin re-learning how to do everything all over again. *g*

Poor Carol. She didn't have to teach me the tech so much, 'cause I used a different program, but she did get stuck teaching me timing, and editing, and...the woman is talented and also, a saint. *g*

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:42 am (UTC)(link)
*g* Man, I can't wait until I can actually get to the point of worrying about stuff like timing and editing, instead of, "Uh, what button do I push now?" It's consoling to know that extremely brainy and adroit people like yourself have also struggled with this stuff, and triumphed!

Join Us!

[identity profile] morgandawn.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 06:21 pm (UTC)(link)
gather ye around, ye new converts and welcome another sister to our midst. Amen.

Can I saw how happy I am you are vidding and making Due South vds?

As for the learning curve -- it is steep (and the road is looongg...) and you will be baffled by many things (hhhm, what does this "Crash Program" button do if I press it). Just remember to save and back up.

Most vid programs need to be swicthed between capture and play to listen to audio. Just wait until your reach the part where the execution of a command won't work unless you REMEMBER TO SELECT THE RIGHT WINDOW OR TIMELINE. That one left me red-faced for a week.

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:46 am (UTC)(link)
Thanks for the welcome to the battered but proud ranks! Now that I've finally figured out how to capture, and actually have some clips to begin monkeying with, I'm starting to actually get a grip on just how looooong that road ahead is.

Most vid programs need to be switched between capture and play to listen to audio.

Ah, OK, that's good to know. I thought I was maybe doing something wrong.

And yes, save! back up! Carol's been very good about drumming this into my brain, though I'll doubtless forget and crash/lose stuff at times.

[identity profile] jackiekjono.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 06:47 pm (UTC)(link)
I am glad we could be of help. It makes me feel better about the fact that I did not spend today learning how to use Final Cut Pro and practicing all of the balance positions from my yoga class like I intended to. Instead, I sat on my butt watching really stupid movies, baked some cookies with raspberry chips in them, and vanquished the Evil Hell-Puzzle of Doom.

Let us know if you have any more problems. I think the next one on the horizon will be this: If you are usng an external capture device like a camera to capture with, make sure you turn it off before you try to preview anything. Otherwise, nothing will play back properly. If you forget, like I always do, turn offthe camera, save the project, quit premiere, then open it up again.
astolat: lady of shalott weaving in black and white (Default)

[personal profile] astolat 2003-09-21 07:03 pm (UTC)(link)
Before turning off the camcorder, you can first try going to Project Settings/General/Playback Settings and turning off "Playback on camcorder/DV device" or whatever it's called. At least on my system, that stops it trying to play back on an external monitor and makes it play back happily on the computer.

[identity profile] jackiekjono.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 07:32 pm (UTC)(link)
you see, even people who have been doing this for a while learn new things every day.

Thank you. : )

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:48 am (UTC)(link)
Hey, yesterday was grey and drizzly and altogether a perfect day for stupid movies, yummy cookies, and rescuing friends from the screaming pits of vidding frustration. If you managed to vanquish a Hell-Puzzle in there too, you're golden!

I don't have a camcorder, so I probably won't need to worry about using external capture devices for a while, but if/when I do, rest assured I'll come crawling to you for help. *g*
heresluck: (Default)

[personal profile] heresluck 2003-09-21 07:44 pm (UTC)(link)
For future reference, you actually don't have to convert the .mp3 to a .wav; you can just use the .mp3.

And if you want to know about capturing through the computer's DVD player, just let me know; I've trial-and-errored my way through it, and am happy to share what I've figured out. It requires several different programs, and thus *looks* a little intimidating, but is not actually all that difficult; the process just has a lot of steps to it.

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:56 am (UTC)(link)
you actually don't have to convert the .mp3 to a .wav; you can just use the .mp3

Gack, you're absolutely right; I'd gotten that mixed up in my head with the format, whatever it is, for stuff taken directly from CDs, which, OK, *that's* the one that needs to be converted, right. Thanks so much! And thank you also for the offer to help me figure out capturing from the computer's DVD player. I will almost certainly take you up on that at some point (probably once the season 3/4 dS DVDs are out, heh).

[identity profile] imkalena.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 09:34 pm (UTC)(link)
convince the non-vidders that they are truly much better off sticking to writing

Um, y'know what?

I'm sold. Your work here is done! :)

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:58 am (UTC)(link)
You, missy, we firmly intend to keep chained to the keyboard, turning out stories! So that's good, then. *g*

Wah!

[identity profile] amand-r.livejournal.com 2003-09-21 09:45 pm (UTC)(link)
You just convined me that I do not want to vid! And I so wanted to make a few anime vids! Argh! And I have Premier. Just as well since I do not have the manual *cough* available with my copy.

*shatteredworldshatteredworldshatteredworld*

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 06:03 am (UTC)(link)
The manual is really *amazingly* useless, at least for a beginner, IMO. I'm looking into stuff like the SAMS guide and "Premiere for Dummies" and suchlike, so I don't have to be bugging friends every five minutes, and one of those might do you instead.

And I mean, hey, if you've got the equipment, and are looking for any reason whatsoever to avoid writing (as well as any necessities of RL like doing dishes or talking to friends), vidding is an *wonderfully* effective timesink. Do not let your world be shattered! Join us, join us! ::mystical beckoning gestures::

[identity profile] jackiekjono.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 06:17 am (UTC)(link)
One of us, one of us. We will make her one of us.

You're making a Victoria vid!

[identity profile] planetalyx.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 09:09 am (UTC)(link)
Can I just say: oooooh!

And while I'm at it, I don't think I've ever mentioned this but your Fresh Hell icon is the wittiest.

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:45 pm (UTC)(link)
*g* Thank you! Pissy!Giles is truly a thing of beauty and a joy forever.

And I have no idea if the vid is actually going to amount to anything, but I'm having more fun than is probably legal playing around with it.

[identity profile] planetalyx.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 09:58 pm (UTC)(link)
The Universe owes you fun. I checked with Billing and you have nothing to worry about on that front.

[identity profile] laurakaye.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 11:32 am (UTC)(link)
I use Premiere EVERY DAY, for my JOB, the job which pays my mortgage, and yet I STILL can't make head or tail of the Premiere manual. It just sucks *that much.*

[identity profile] katallison.livejournal.com 2003-09-22 05:48 pm (UTC)(link)
This is very reassuring -- I figured it was probably just that I'm dense or something.

I bought the SAMS "Teach Yourself Premiere in 24 Hours" book today, and am actually finding it very helpful. The author starts from the assumption that his readers have already leapt in and begun messing about, and he does a good job of walking one through how to do various things, without getting too complicated. Plus, the illustrations are very good.